Thursday, 19 December 2013

Experiences of supervision in the children's workforce: a pilot study

A pilot study was carried out via a seven-item, online questionnaire; participants (n40) were recruited through facebook , linkedin, and Chris Taylor Solutions website. The questionnaire was open for 21 days. Almost two-thirds of respondents are responsible for supervising others as well as receiving supervision themselves. Although respondents overwhelmingly value supervision as important to their carrying out their work (94%) more than a third (37%) do not receive regular supervision. Most respondents who do not receive regular supervision still value it as important for them carrying out their job well. Worryingly, perhaps, the majority of respondents who do not receive regular supervision are working in a regulated sector where supervision is a requirement to meet National Minimum Standards. Over 80% felt that supervision was important for providing emotional support, and its function in learning and development was valued equally. These qualities are usually associated with clinical supervision and might be expected to be less pronounced in line management arrangements. Given the emotional labour and complexity of working with (often vulnerable) children and young people, this is encouraging. Supervision is also widely valued for ensuring tasks are done (about 60%) but only about half of the respondents considered enhanced safeguarding as one of its functions. When it was part of their job role, respondents overwhelmingly said they had received adequate training to provide supervision, although a small number (6%) said they had not been trained adequately. Slightly more (12%) responded that they had not been trained sufficiently in receiving supervision, and it is perhaps encouraging that most had. This is a small scale study, and these data should be treated with some caution; however, as a pilot it introduces some useful themes for further research. Perhaps one of the starkest figures is that over one third of the sample does not receive regular supervision, although it is overwhelmingly valued and in some cases required by National Minimum Standards. The survey did not enquire into respondents’ emotional experiences of supervision (do they look forward to it, or perhaps dread it). Neither did it examine the contextual factors that influence its regularity. There was no examination of quality of usefulness / outcomes, and these are all aspects for further research.

Tuesday, 12 November 2013

A brief psychosocial assessment

Assessment is a process, not a single event. Done well, this process begins with a base-line assessment to decide an initial approach and develops into a virtuous cycle of intervention, review and updating so that progress is built on and obstacles are addressed. The child assessment framework described here is not a comprehensive psychological or psychiatric assessment, but a brief, systematic process to acquire an accurate, thorough picture of a young person’s strengths and weaknesses, whilst acknowledging that any assessment is to some degree a product of, and dependent on, the environment in which the assessment occurs. The framework combines the “lived experience” of residential staff or foster carers working alongside the young person with psychologically and therapeutically guided observation and recording, professional judgement, clinical interviews, questionnaires and psychometric tools. Since outcomes are not only measured in changes in symptoms or problem behaviours, but also in an improved feeling of engagement, a greater capacity to seek, accept and provide support, and increased social activity, this assessment method takes account of the young person’s strengths and soft skills as well as their difficulties and reveals protective factors, deficits, needs and risks. The assessment can also point to empirically supported intervention strategies. Although every assessment is different, usually data are collected over the period of a month. Every effort is made to complete the analysis and write-up within another month, and a completed assessment report is usually submitted two months from starting

Friday, 8 November 2013

Defining and responding to complex needs

The term “complex needs” is used to convey several different ideas sometimes specifically, and most often interchangeably. They include: “multiple disadvantage”, “multiple disabilities”, “multiple impairment”, “dual diagnosis”, “high support needs” and “multiple and complex needs”. Perhaps more usefully, complex needs can be thought of as implying both the breadth of need (multiple needs that are interrelated or interconnected) and the depth of need (profound, severe, serious or intense) and a combination of both. This is captured in The Department for Education definition of children with complex needs as having “a number of discrete needs that require additional support from more than one agency. Their needs are often chronic and may be lifelong. Different needs tend to interact, exacerbating their impact on the child's development and well-being.” Rather than use the term complex needs solely to describe an individual's characteristics, we also need to think about the wider social context of their lives. These young people may also be marginalised, present as high risk, and be hard to reach, and it is useful to also consider how current service arrangements and factors of poverty and exclusion impact on meeting multiple and complex needs; that is to recognise that children with complex needs are found in a social context and that in order to help we need to think of multiple, interlocking needs that span psychological, emotional, behavioural, health and social issues. Because these children are at the extreme of a continuum of needs they pose the greatest challenges to services. The term itself may be stigmatising, restricting access to some mainstream services. The broad and deep nature of the young person’s needs is often a contributing factor in placement breakdown, school exclusion and peer isolation. Complex needs can place a child on a self-fulfilling downward cycle of: • Placement disruption; • Seemingly growing needs and greater complexity; • Greater difficulty in finding out what will help them settle; • Further placement disruption. It can also be more difficult to meet basic needs (like dental and healthcare needs) because of issues around access and motivation, and their cultural identity needs can easily become ignored. In addition, judgements of success and failure are often made without clear understanding the level of complexity that these children may present. Enduring patterns of behaviour are unlikely to be changed easily; above all, these young people require time. For young people in the Looked After system, the breadth and depth of need may be hard to see: some may have major mental health needs in addition to other impairments; others may have additional difficulties with communication; many have difficulties that result from maltreatment and unstable, fractured lives. These young people present a challenge for services and for commissioners. In general, children with complex needs are not well served by provisions established to meet more general levels of difficulty, and even within specialist services it is not simple to understand what any individual young person may need to turn their life around. What is needed is a flexible and inclusive service that is able to assess, identify and meet individual needs. As well as the willingness to tolerate some uncertainty, it is necessary to develop understanding whilst working sensitively and knowledgeably with the particular issues for each young person. This must be founded on the expectation that young people will be involved in the assessment process, recognising that they are not only their difficulties and that they also have strengths, talents, interests and abilities. Whilst careful assessment is the basis of successful work with young people with complex needs, it is important to acknowledge the often deleterious effect of multiple assessments. Ethically, the point of assessment is to lead to helpful interventions, and yet, in complex cases, assessment can become an end in itself; faced with little sense of how to help it is easy to return for more assessments, but perhaps we should first be clear how this additional burden on the young person will help. Young people with complex needs that arise from maltreatment are likely to also present with “challenging behaviours”. Agreeing appropriate ways to provide care, protection and control can be highly problematic for young people who place huge pressures on those who work with them day-to-day. It is essential that we all try to take the young person’s perspective; their welfare must be paramount, and any responses to behaviour must be in the young person’s best interest and be part of a long-term plan to meet needs and encourage recovery. When deciding on therapeutic approaches and interventions we need to consider five key questions: 1. What research is available? 2. For who does this approach work best? 3. What alternatives might be tried? 4. How is a decision made to follow one course of action? 5. How is that decision reviewed and evaluated? We also need to consider the extent to which they are settled and stable before beginning more intense work. Many young people in specialist residential care have broad and deep needs, these needs are multiple and enduring. A helpful approach is to try to understand the individual, to keep sight of their perspective, to provide care, support and protection to help them turn their lives around. It is important to acknowledge that this difficult task is likely to also be slow, and that as well as providing individual therapies and treatments, much of the work to meet their wider social and psychological needs takes place in the wider, living-learning environments of home and school. What we most want is that, overcoming complex needs, our young people are able to get a successful life of their own.

Thursday, 22 August 2013

Why We Might Be Curious

Perhaps our work with vulnerable young people is not so much a job as a belief; a belief that the young people we work with can and will make progress and have decent, fulfilling and satisfying lives. It seems to me that one of the most useful ways we can contribute to this belief being true is though our own curiosity about our young people. When we observe a young person behave a certain way we often explain their behaviour based on a kind of certainty about their motives or intentions. Hit hard by an angry child, we might think to ourselves “they want to hurt me,” or even “they didn’t want to hurt me”. Same action, perceived in different ways, and our response to this action is likely to be highly influenced by our thoughts about their intentions. Unfortunately, even if we know the person well (and often in our work we do not) we may well be wrong. And if we are wrong about their mental state, we may not respond effectively. Additionally, we might happily say why (in our opinion) a young person acted as they have, even though they may not really know why themselves. I’d like to suggest that such certainty is not likely to be helpful. What we believe about ourselves and others can become a self-fulfilling prophecy because we tend to act in accordance to what we believe. Further, our inborn potential to give more weight to information that confirms what we already think than we do to information that contradicts it (called confirmation bias) means we often experiences our beliefs as being supported by the evidence before our eyes. It may be more useful to be curious about their mental and emotional state than to be certain, and that to be curious about why a child does certain things and cannot do others is one of the most helpful things we can do. There is something special about curiosity, to really sense, hear, feel what life is like for the child, and showing genuine interest in their thoughts, values, beliefs and intentions. Previously, drawing on John Bolwby’s suggestion about how therapists may best help their patients, I suggested that in our work we may help our young people not so much by interpreting things for them, but by being a “companion for…exploration”. A key tool to this companionship is curiosity. The American psychotherapist Dan Hughes highlights how the first shared state between an infant and their primary caregiver is one of acceptance and curiosity, love and playfulness. Murphey & Joffe said that “creating a caring relationship requires genuine curiosity.” It is through shared curiosity that the child first experiences being in the mind of their attachment figure, who is curious enough about the emotional tone of the child’s communication to respond in an attuned way. Being curious frees us from the need to always having to “solve” difficulties. This can take enormous pressure of us, and can be hugely validating for the child. This does not imply we do nothing, but that what we can do is to be curious about the meanings of events and behaviours and curious about possible causes of action. For me, to genuinely be curious is one of the great skills of our work; it is our genuine interest in our young person’s thoughts and feelings and respect for their perspectives. Curiosity sits in the long tradition of therapeutic working. The approach applied in therapeutic communities, which employ the planned use of social interactions and processes, is founded on a “culture of enquiry”. Without curiosity, the child’s behaviour means only what they act out. Curiosity allows us to not lose sight of the efforts the child is making to build a relationship with us. Also, curiosity is the anti-dote to avoidance (a common response to trauma). Our curiosity about the child in the here-and-now builds a bond of trust, respect and reliability and provides the foundations for new, healthy attachments; when someone is genuinely curious about us, it causes us to be reflective, to wonder about ourselves, and we have a sense of being special, and our genuine curiosity in the here-and-now expresses our attempt to think into the inner world of our young person. Rather than being certain about why a child has acted a certain way, we might be curious about many things: • Why things are the way they are? • How it is that this person came to be in this situation? • How one might we help? • What will happen if you do something (or do nothing)? • To wonder about who this person is • What their experience of themselves is? • What it is like to be them? • What are their intentions, motives, goals and thoughts? • What are they feeling? • What am I thinking and feeling, and why am I? It is also useful to be curious about outcomes. How can we be confident enough that our young people are making progress? Change is often messy, and a young person’s recovery from the difficult circumstances of their life is unlikely to be a smooth, constantly improving path. It is much more likely to me a rollercoaster, sometimes moving forward, sometime going back; sometimes progress might unlock previously unseen difficulties. An example of this might be a young person who for years has turned anger about their experiences inwards and only expressed it by hurting themselves beginning to express their anger more outwardly (but still not appropriately) by acting it out more directly on the world around them. This uncertainty about progress and outcomes is one important reason why we need to try and measure change through some objective means.

Resilience in Residential Childcare and Fostering

If our work is somehow walking alongside the child as they explore their inner world (Bowlby’s “companion for exploration”) then we need to be as well-equipped as we can be. However, at this point we need to acknowledge a difficulty. Training and personal development programmes should provide the skills and knowledge to do the task (the explorers’ tools), but the hard emotional labour of looking after our young people also requires some personal qualities. This is the “stuff” of explorers that is beyond any training programme. This “stuff” includes a deep emotional pool on which to draw; ability to step outside the immediate feelings brought up by the child’s difficulties; insight to see their behaviour for what it is...communication; and capacity to come back in the face of repeated rejections (“stickability” and “bouncebackability”). These qualities (there are undoubtedly others) might be referred to as resilience. Resilience is usually thought of as having three layers. First there is an inner layer of personal qualities and inner strengths, including a secure sense of our own identity, healthy self-esteem, belief in our ability to influence the world, and beliefs and experiences of success. As adults, this is largely our own “stuff”; our own individual responsibility, and we cannot reasonably look outside ourselves to be given these things. We have acquired them, to a greater or lesser degree, as part of the trajectory of our own lives. Those of you interested in attachment theory will no doubt reflect on the role that a secure childhood attachment can play in providing the foundation for this. Resilience is not just these personal qualities, it is also produced and supported by the connections we have to other people. In other words, an individual’s capacity to “stick with it” and to “bounce back” depends in part on their character and in part on their network of close and supportive others (families and friends). It is a sad fact that the anti-social hours of the work can take its toll on our families and friends, but knowing this can encourage us to work hard enough to maintain these much needed connections. The third layer of resilience is usually called community. This is the degree to which we are connected to something wider than our immediate supportive circle, the way we feel we have a place in the world and feel that we belong, that we have a purpose and are fulfilled by our daily lives. It is important that we connect with our own work community and with communities beyond our own work place. This is in part the stuff of the therapeutic community, but it is also the stuff of teams, of working together, of integrating and sharing with colleagues from different disciplines, and the stuff of looking outside our own organisation to the wider community of childcare (a helpful social worker, a conference, journals and magazines, web-discussion forums, and so on, all connect us to the wider community, even, perhaps, helpful blogs). It is also management structures, supervision, mentoring, buddying systems and formal and informal networks of colleagues. It’s worth mentioning here that, as well as receiving support and developing our resilience in these community contacts, we are also there to provide support and sustain the resilience of others in these communities (that’s what a community is) and to be as ready to give support as we are to need it. Perhaps these are rare things, although I see them daily in the people around me in my own organisation. If you know people with this “stuff”, and they like children and want an interesting and varied career, perhaps you should think about recruiting them to a fascinating and rewarding career. If you see gaps in this stuff in yourself or in your colleagues (and gaps will appear for none of us is unbreakable) then perhaps you could think about how to help.

Social Control Theory

There is a widely held, informal theory of child development that unwanted behaviours will somehow be “switched off” if they attract sufficiently disadvantageous responses, a kind of informal, social learning approach. However, there is little empirical support for this idea. One of the ideas put forward by the Chicago School in the 1920s & 30s is that violating social norms is potentially so pleasurable that we should perhaps be more interested in finding out what constrains people from doing so more often than they do. Social Control Theory (Hirschi) suggests that individuals are constrained from anti-social behaviours by four types of control: 1. Inner controls that result from internalizing pro-social beliefs and values. I would add to this the idea that pro-social values take root more readily when the individual has an internal representation of themselves and others as worthwhile. 2. Outer controls, which are typically social and economic sanctions. I would add to this the point that many traumatized children will not experience typical social sanctions as unwanted. One example would be that negative attention from a telling-off might be preferred to no attention at all 3. Indirect controls that arise through identification with, for example, a victims discomfort or a parent’s disapproval. I would add to this the idea that such identification requires a degree of empathy that may be inhibited in traumatized children 4. Satisfaction of needs. Anti-social behaviour may arise as a way of satisfying needs, from material needs for possessions though to internal needs such as power, revenge and control. If the individual can satisfy these needs in legitimate ways then the need for anti-social behaviour is reduced. The imposition of outer controls (sanctions) may well increase a need for revenge, power and control, and therefore increase rather than decrease unwanted behaviour. Outer controls and indirect controls can only be effective at “switching off” unwanted behaviour if an individual has a degree of self-control; they clearly cannot be effective if there are significant impulse control difficulties. This also applies to earning rewards and privileges, or gaining levels. We also know (e.g. from the Cambridge Study of Delinquency Development, Farrington, 1990) that delinquent behaviour is more likely when an individual’s social bonds are weakened or diminished. The combination of low levels of affection and the failure to adequately protect a child is both traumatising and associated with weak bonding, and so children who are traumatized in their families are at high risk of exhibiting a wide range of unwanted behaviours. The problem with social learning approaches for this group of children is that both the earning of rewards and the loosing of privileges weaken, rather than strengthen, bonds. Another reason sometimes put forward for reward-punishment approaches to unwanted behaviour is that all children need opportunities to learn about the consequences of their actions. This is undoubtedly true, but we have to be careful what the child is learning. From the exertion of adult power they may learn that they are small and powerless and what they really want is revenge. But there cannot be a problem with exerting some level of discipline; the question is more of how it is done, and why. Getting a child to help clear up a mess they’ve made, or making them wait a little for something they want to do, can help them make amends, teach as sense of consequence, promote experience of delayed gratification, and distinguish wanted behaviours from unwanted. However, it is essential that the use of consequences is accompanied by good quality explanation and genuine, authentic warmth. Explanation promotes the child’s ability to generalize to other situations, and authentic warmth allows the child to experience discipline as a supportive intervention for their benefit, rather than the exercise of adult power.

Friday, 1 June 2012

Emphatic Care for Children with Disorganized Attachments

A new book by Chris Taylor, Emphatic Care for Children with Disorganized Attachments: A Model for Mentalizing, Attachment and Trauma-Informed Care is published by Jessica Kingsley Publishers in July this year. Disorganized attachment is the most extreme form of insecure attachment. This book is a practical guide to caring for children and young people with disorganized attachment and related emotional and psychological difficulties. Synthesising attachment, trauma and mentalization theory into a useful practice model, Empathic Care for Children with Disorganized Attachments proposes ways of meeting the needs arising in children and young people with disorganized attachments. Focusing on the importance of interpersonal bonds to facilitate the child's capacity to mentalize, it aims to equip the reader with the appropriate skills to provide effective, sustained and, most importantly, empathic care to the most vulnerable and troubled children. This structured psychotherapeutic approach to caregiving will enable the development of child–carer relationships and can be used to create informed, safe environments that support both the young person and the caregiver. This useful guide is invaluable to health and social care professionals including residential carers, therapists, counsellors, and those working with vulnerable and troubled children and young people including those supporting foster and adoptive families.

Wednesday, 28 September 2011

Disordered eating

People can develop difficulties with food for a number of reasons, but it is clear that some young people with severe attachment difficulties cope with self and interpersonal difficulties by employing a range of self-destructive behaviours, including disordered eating. Working with this group is difficult and requires some specialist intervention, but there are also a few basic principles that can help.
Crucial principles
• No one chooses to have disordered eating, although the child can seem very attached to theirs. Usually an individual would want to give up their disordered eating if they knew how. Attempts to help can be frightening, because the disordered eating has some advantages
• The disordered eating serves a purpose. Resistance to change and resistance to help are part of the condition, and do not mean that your child is being deliberately difficult, rather it reflects their fears of giving up something that helps with other problematic areas of life.
• Poor self-esteem can be a crucial underlying issue
• There is no quick and easy solution
Fundamentals of management
• Try not to blame the child for her disordered eating
• Accept the child is in distress
• There is no single correct way of helping, but the whole team around the child need to identify and support strategies for working with the disordered eating, and all need to consistently apply them. Finding everyone working together in harmony can provide the child the confidence she needs to overcome her disorder
• The things you do to help need time to work. Be consistent, persistent and repetitive
• Try not to lose sight of the healthy and good things about the child. Get a full and complete picture of her strengths. Try to do the normal things the child enjoys
• Try to separate the disordered eating from the person. This difficulty does not make them a bad person. It’s a bad thing that is happening to a good person
• Away from meals, try to focus on your child’s feelings. Show her that you can acknowledge and accept them. Offer warmth, comfort and reassurance
In cases of anorexia
In cases of anorexia and similar conditions, it’s as if the child has two inner voices. The “anorexic” voice telling her that she is “fat, ugly and stupid” and the “healthy voice” telling her she is “ill, thin and should eat” The first voice is experienced by everyone as louder and more insistent. Try to focus on the healthy voice along the following lines:
I know how strong the voice is that tells you, you are fat and shouldn’t eat; how sometimes it torments you and at others it seems to be your friend. It must be confusing and frightening for you. But I want to speak to the healthy part of you, so I’m not going to talk to the part of you that torments you in that way

Thursday, 26 May 2011

Are care leavers resilient enough for the huge task they face?

Are care leavers resilient enough for the huge task they face? One answer is “yes”; some young people leave care and establish themselves satisfactorily in adult life and thrive in the face of life’s ups and downs. But I imagine we all know young people who face a very different reality; who struggle to live well or cope. Comparing most outcomes for these young people to the general population makes a gloomy picture: more likely to be in prison or hospital, to be pregnant early, to have their own children in care, to misuse substances, to be victims of crime, to be homeless.
All this is often used to show how poorly the care system does for the young people that to care well for is its sole ‘raison-d’etre, although of course it shows no such thing. What it does show is that kids with difficult beginnings have the odds stacked against them throughout life. To know whether the care system helps or not (I suspect that it does sometimes, and doesn’t others) you would need to compare young people in care with a similar group of young people not in care. And that can never be done, because if you found such a group of children you would have to act, to intervene, to bring them the safeguarding and services that the care system brings their Looked After peers.
But, without trying to evaluate the work we do through the use of ill-matched comparison groups, I suspect none of us would deny the “life stacked against them” s experiences of care leavers. Now that’s a big topic, so I’m only going to look at part of it here, that part we call “resilience”.
Resilience can simply be defined as they ability to thrive in adverse circumstances – bouncebackability is a good word for it. We often think of it as a set of personal attributes or characteristics, but Daniel and Wessel suggest that this quality is best thought of from an ecological perspective. An ecological model of resilience says that this ability to bounce back is woven from aspects both of the person and their environment. I like that way of thinking, and the ideas expressed here follow from it.
So, resilience is in part the individual and in part their environment. Let’s return to care leavers. A substantial number of young people come into care with complex, multiple and enduring needs. These needs, which frequently include difficulties forming, sustaining and trusting close relationships, are often poorly understood and contribute to multiple placements which further disrupt the child’s over all functioning. Many are criminalized and given up on; their pathway to adult difficulties strengthened by a system that turns its back on their needs in favour of cheaper alternatives. 50 placements by age 11 is not that uncommon, but even a smaller number is a trail of rejection and failure that is internalized by the child, who nearly always feels that a placement that has ended is their fault. Some get more help than this, a placement is able to meet their needs, to “hold onto” them, to keep them in mind and promote a pathway to recovery, to help them develop many of the individual skills and characteristics that form part of resilience: self-mastery, self-regulation, problem-solving, self-awareness, healthy self-esteem, settled identity, talents & interests, positive values, social competence…the list goes on. And yet, even with this remarkable list, the young person is still at risk of not being resilient enough; however many personal attributes we have, we need stuff outside us, ecological stuff, to be resilient, and here, once again, careleavers are disadvantaged.
The first ecological layer is family. Individuals who have close and supportive ties with families, or with people to whom they belong, are more likely to thrive in adverse circumstances. Of course this is true; supportive families and good friends help each other when they can, and they provide comfort and nurture at times of stress and distress; a safe haven to fly to when times are hard. For many, this safe haven is established in interaction with caring caregivers in their early development, for others it is acquired through enough care later, including stability, working through relational difficulties, solving problems, being valued and belonging. Without it where do you go when it all gets too much? 50 placements by age 18 is not so uncommon…and children that did not have this early, with complex and enduring needs, get good at keeping it away later
The outer ecological layer is community. Again this is disrupted, both by the system and by the way the child copes with their complex, multiple and enduring difficulties. Even if they have succeeded in placement and been stable, and put down roots, they are increasingly likely to be forced back to the risky world they have temporarily escaped. And once they are 18, the resources all but dry up.
I’ve worked with these children and young people for over twenty-two years. I’m interested in therapeutic working, and believe I have contributed to the growth of the personal characteristics of resilience for many individuals. I also believe that I have helped them find a safe haven in good relationships with caregivers and with friends, and I’ve worked hard to support the growth of community networks. And I know I am not alone, staff I have worked with, and other individuals and organizations, work effectively to promote recovery from poor early beginnings, to work, as we say, therapeutically. But society must also accept its role and recognize that the needs of individuals who have come from difficult beings are complex and enduring; its not their fault, they didn’t choose to be neglect or abused as a child, and if they need external support after care they should have it; it takes time to build resilience and autonomy, and prisons, hospitals and homeless hostels are full of people who were given neither the time or the support to do so.

Tuesday, 3 May 2011

Managing behaviours – not what a child does, by why they do it

Behaviours have a purpose and serve a need. When a child has unwanted behaviours we need to prioritise: changing long-held coping strategies and unwanted habits is hard, takes time, and requires helpful and supportive relationships. Children will probably not change their behaviours just because we want them to. They need opportunity to develop new, more adaptive skills, and to model acceptable behaviour.

Don’t forget that a child does not need to perform a behaviour to model it, it is enough that behaviour is observed for the child to incorporate it into their repertoire. The “modelling ratio” is probably 100:1, that is, a child needs to see a new behaviour consistently (up to 100 times) in order to incorporate the new behaviour into their repertoire, but only needs to see an existing behaviour once in order to have it confirmed that this is a satisfactory way of acting. Suddenly, being a “good role model” doesn’t seem so easy; how many little bits of negative social behaviour do we bring to our own interactions with kids, with colleagues, with parents, with strangers? It is also worth remembering that modelling is a more powerful influence than conditioning; that is, a child learns more about how to behave from how they experience significant others around them behaving toward them, or see them acting toward others (children and adults) than attempts to change behaviour through rewards or sanctions (conditioning).

It is important to recognize that behaviours (good and bad) happen in a context, and that the context in which a person acts is at least as important in deciding their behaviour as their personal characteristics and learnt behaviours. Hardly seems possible does it, but true none the less. Therefore, in considering how to help a child develop alternatives to unwanted behaviour, we must take account of the context in which the behaviour occurs.

The first step towards change is to create a hierarchy of behaviours to focus on – it cannot be possible to change all behaviours at once. The maximum number is three, and if these behaviours are coping strategies, they will need to be replaced with more adaptive ways of coping that work for the child.

In order to encourage change you need reliable data; what does the child do, where do they do it, what else is going on, etc. A data grid is useful, for each target beahviour:
• Date
• Time
• Duration
• Antecedents – what was going on before?
• Accurate description of behaviour
• Describe what happened as a result of the behaviour
• List all the people this was a problem for
• Explain for each why it was a problem
• What is the child’s perception of what happened - you may need to get this information later
• Were they able to identify a goal they had in mind when they behaved like this?
• What function (purpose) do you think the behaviour served?

These data need to be analysed in order to plan effective interventions. We should always ask more about why a child does something than about what they do.

Saturday, 12 February 2011

Transference and countertransference

As concepts, transference and counter transference essentially derive from Freud. Although empirical human behavioural sciences have moved on from many of his ideas, the usefulness of these two concepts to clinicians remains, and they are seen as essential elements in the therapeutic relationships; elements that need to be recognized, understood, and worked with. I think most psychotherapists would say that we need to be thoroughly trained in working with transference / countertransference, and I would not disagree that that would be useful; however, that is not likely to happen for residential staff and foster carers, and yet they will go through this process many times in their work. So it seems useful, in the spirit of working therapeutically, rather than being a therapist, for front line staff and their managers to have affirm grasp of the processes involved.
The other aspect of the therapeutic relationship is the therapeutic alliance. The therapeutic alliance is the rational relationship that exists between the child and the therapeutic worker; it is the mutual understanding that the one needs help, support and assistance and that it is the other’s role to provide it. This may be an overt and uncomplicated therapeutic relationship, but in many cases it is complicated by “unconscious” expectations of close relationships that have grown out of past trauma, relational failure, and unresolved separation and loss.
Transference involves the projection of a mental representation of a previous experience onto the present, transferring an inappropriate aspect of a past relationship onto the other person in the therapeutic relationship. (It is not inappropriate to mistrust someone who let you down in the past and therefore to mistrust someone who lets you down now, but it is inappropriate to assume someone will let you down in the here and now when they have never done so).
Transference is much more likely when the child / young person is under real or imagined threat, and when they have rigid and inflexible personality traits (e.g in individuals who show signs of borderline personality disorder).
Transference needs managing, or it will wreck the therapeutic relationship:
• Recognize the importance of the relationship to the child / young person(this happens when we get close)
• Maintain professional boundaries, and be aware of professional ways of working and responding so we can recognize when we begin to act in response to transference
• Not being pulled into complementary roles that reinforce transference
• Reflecting and interpreting these experiences for the child / young person at a pace and level that is bearable for them.
Countertransference is the response elicited in the worker by the child / young person’s communication of their distressing experiences through transference, and includes the feelings that are evoked in the worker (e.g. helplessness, hostility, fear). Countertransference can be a useful guide to the child’s experiences (e.g. being helpless, rejection, threat). Melanie Klein developed the idea of countertransference by recognizing that it could flow in both directions. I think you see this very strongly when placements are under pressure: adults may feel overwhelmed and needing a break (transferring fear and failure on the child / young person), and this elicits feelings of blame and rejection in the child (countertransference). Staff can feel very responsible for the troubling feelings engendered by the work, and become defensive, whereas understanding that these feelings may have been elicited in them by the distressed child, and can be seen as a window on their inner world, can reduce feelings of being overwhelmed and/or blamed, and therefore reduce the need to be defensive.
Countertransference also needs to be worked with:
• Countertransference is more easily recognized when it is out of character with how we would usually feel or respond
• It requires reflection: a reasonable level of self-awareness, a questioning attitude towards our own feelings and motives, recognition that we all have “blind spots”
• Understanding that we are all affected by the child / young person’s distress, although in different ways,
• Recognizing that they will have strong feelings for us (both negative and positive)
One of the most useful helping resources is the team; sharing our countertransference experiences to clarify what the child / young person projects onto each of us, and unpicking what these feelings tell us about the child / young person’s experience in the here and now. Another useful resource is external consultancy, both for the team and for individuals. It is important that understanding of the internal changes implicit in these processes are matched to individual’s own typical self-defence style; that is if an individual tends to become enmeshed in a child / young person’s difficulties, they need help to process feeling of rejection, but if they tend to dismiss these difficulties as behavioural, they need help in understanding the link between the behaviour and early trauma.

Friday, 11 February 2011

Placement stability and attachments: two strands in a single braid

Many Looked-After Children and Young People have difficulties around their early attachments that cast long shadows over the present. At some level, all children living away from home will have experienced loss and separation, but a significant number will have developed insecure attachments that make this loss and separation more difficult to handle. Estimates vary, but between 25 and 40% of children across the country may be insecurely attached. However, experience tells us that Looked-After Children are more frequently anxious in their attachments than the general population.

Looking after children with attachment difficulties is demanding work. Their very difficulties make relationships difficult, and placements are at risk through impoverished relational abilities. However, what such children need most is stability. Stability requires commitment from commissioners and expertise from providers. Without these, placements are tenuous, uncertain and unstable, which creates further difficulties for the child in developing secure relationships. Coming into care is often about safeguarding, and rightly so, but, when a child has had a difficult early life, being in care should also be about recovery and opportunity.

Children possess an attachment system that is activated as soon as an internal or external threat appears; if their own resources are insufficient to eliminate the danger, attachment behaviours are triggered. These feelings, expectations and behaviours are directed towards an attachment figure, who is selected by the child on the basis of proximity and availability. This is the child’s first experience of an intimate relationship; it balances safety and exploration and over the first years of life, as the developing child becomes more aware of the inner world of others, it becomes a reciprocal relationship. The degree to which the child learns to trust the relationship is dependent on the quality of the attachment figures responses to the child’s need for safety and exploration. Good enough care promotes secure relationships, but constant failures in caregiving leave the child feeling anxious and insecure.

Attachment theory is a theory of human development across the life span. As we become older the nature of our attachment relationships change, the circumstances that elicit attachment behaviours alter, our attachment behaviours mature, but the need for this primary bond remains. Initially, attachment security can be seen as a function of the relationship between the child and the attachment figure. However, as the child develops, these early encounters become internalized, and the attachment pattern established early in life becomes increasingly a property of the child themselves. The good news is that these patterns are not unchangeable; rather they represent developmental pathways probable unless there is a change in caregiving. However, although attachment style is amenable to change, the way that attachment is organized has been shown to be highly stable over time.
Attachment organization represents a coherent way for the child to achieve the maximum bearable proximity to their attachment figure at times of threat and maintain the maximum bearable distance for exploration. However, some children are so dazed and confused by their early experiences that that they cannot form a coherent strategy, and are seen as disorganized and disoriented.

Disorganized attachment is not uncommon, but is more widespread in families with low social economic status. Van Ijzendoorn et al (1999) suggest that as many as 15 – 25% of children have disorganized attachment, but that this rises to 43% in families with substance abuse, and 48% in maltreating families. This, along with observational data, suggests that many socially excluded children have a disorganized pattern of attachment.

Allen et al (1996) have shown substantial links between adolescent attachment organization and mental health. They found in a clinical sample that preoccupied adolescents were highly sensitive to parental responses: if met with parenting responses that were passive or enmeshed, they showed internalizing symptoms such as depression and anxiety, but with rejecting or ignoring parental responses, preoccupied adolescents show externalizing responses, becoming involved in delinquency, substance misuse and promiscuity. Encouragingly, positive friendships reduced delinquency.

In contrast, dismissing adolescents were less influenced by parental reciprocation; they coped by distracting themselves and others from their attachment cues through substance abuse and conduct problems.

Kiriakardis (2006) investigated the backgrounds and beliefs of 152 young offenders, using the Parental Bonding Instrument (Parker et al 1979) and self-reports of beliefs and attitudes around reoffending. He found that maternal over-protection correlated with both intentions to reoffend and positive views of offending behaviour, whereas, offenders who recalled high levels of parental care evaluated their offending behaviour more negatively.

Good care in a planned therapeutic environment can be therapeutic, but multiple placements and changing caregiving styles can further disorganize the child’s inner world. Not all children who come into care have the same degree of difficulties. Clough et al (2006) suggest a framework:
 Tier 1: Relatively simple & straightforward needs: Placements may be stable because they are relatively low cost.
 Tier 2: Deep rooted, complex needs: Difficulties often emerge with adolescence, putting strain on possible fairly stable placements, however, placement moves may disorganize attachments.
 Tier 3: Extensive, complex & enduring needs: This group of children / young people require expertise, support, long-term commitment, and they may require support beyond childhood.

Whilst short-term, timely intervention may be sufficient for the first group of children, for those in the other groups only carefully planned and skilfully delivered caregiving (which exceeds normal good parenting) is needed (Cameron & Maginn, (2009). Those with enduring needs may well require levels of support that are not available after leaving care, so drift into adult mental health or prisons.
But recovery is possible. A critical idea is the planned environment; by working with attachment in mind, caregivers provide a secure base for the child to explore relationships in the here and now, promoting cognitive restructuring, and safely containing and expressing emotions (Taylor, 2010).

The child’s experience of being in care should be one of recovery, but we have to ask critical questions about the quality of a service that for many children seems to replicate the disorganizing factors of their early experiences.

Recommendations
 Support therapeutic approaches that keep attachment in mind in social settings and through individual psychotherapy
 Develop a two-strand, integrated approach: a therapeutic social milieu and individual work
 Interventions should take account of how to maintain the child/young person’s safe relationships

References:
Allen, J.P., Hauser, S.T., and Borman-Spurrell, E. (1996). Attachment theory as a framework for understanding sequelae of severe adolescent psychopathology: An 11-year follow-up study. Journal of Clinical Psychology. 64(2): 254-263.
Bogaerts, S., Vanheule, S., & Declercq, F. (2005). Recalled parental bonding, adult attachment style, and personality disorders in child molesters: A comparative study. Journal of Forensic Psychiatry and Psychology, 16(3), 445-458.
Cameron, R. J., & Maginn. C. (2009). Achieving Positive Outcomes for Children in Care. Sage: London.
Clough, R. Bullock, R. & Ward, A. (2006) What Works in Residential Child Care. London: NCERCC & National Children’s Bureau.
Haapsalo, J., Puupponen, M., and Crittenden, P. M. (1999). Victim to victimizer: The psychology of isomorphism in a case of a recidivist pedophile in Finland. Journal of Child Sexual Abuse, 7, 97-115.
Kiriakardis, S.P. (2006). Perceived parental care and supervision: a relation with cognitive representations of future offending in a sample of young offenders. International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology. 50 (2): 187-203.
Liska, A.E., and Reed, M.D. (1985). Ties to conventional institutions and delinquency: estimating reciprocal effects. American Sociological Review. 50(4): 547-560.
Sampson, R. J. & Laub J. H. (2005). A Life-Course View of the Development of Crime. Annals of the American Academy of Politics and Social Science, 602, 12-45.
Smallbone, S.W., and Dadds, M.R. (1998). Childhood attachment and adult attachment in incarcerated adult male sex offenders. Journal of Interpersonal Violence. 13: 555-573.
Taylor, C.J. (2010). A Practical Guide to Caring for Children and Teenagers with Attachment Difficulties. London and Philadelphia: Jessica Kingsley Publishing.
van Ijzendoorn, M. H., Schuengel, C. & Bakers-Kranenberg, M. J. (1999). Disorganized attachment in early childhood: Meta-analysis of precursors, concomitants, and sequelae, Development and Psychopathology 11, 225-246.

Thursday, 9 December 2010

Social Disadvantage and Looked After Children

Looked after children are living away from home against a backdrop of social exclusion and disadvantage. Those in residential care are likely to be the children who present the most complex difficulties. This is often cyclical. Research that compares parenting styles to the results of the Adult Attachment Interview (Main and Goldwyn, 1984) demonstrates that children with insecure patterns of attachment are likely to have difficulty as parents in creating a secure attachment with their own children. Although attachment is a lifelong process, early childhood experiences influence adult life. Personal, Cultural and Structural disadvantages impact on healthy development, emotional well-being and mental heath. Further, they are likely to reduce opportunities to escape deprivation. Jobs and decent life circumstances are often closed to them. Their anti-social behaviour may have criminalized them; poor attachment patterns may jeopardize a lifetime of relationships.

‘Since discrimination of all kinds is an everyday occurrence in many children’s lives, every effort must be made to ensure that agency services and practices do not reflect or reinforce it.’ (Neil Thompson). Many of the children we care for will be subjected to discrimination for several reasons; being in care itself is reason for stigma in the eyes of many people. As we work, we should attempt to reduce, undermine and eliminate discrimination and oppression, specifically in terms of challenging sexism, racism, ageism and disableism. We can acknowledge the structural and cultural influences on our behaviour and attitudes. Language plays an important part in constructing and maintaining discrimination and other oppressive forms of practice. Failure to act against discrimination is in itself a form of unintentional discrimination. Gently challenging any discriminatory or prejudiced remarks that the children may hold or express is part of our duty of care, to the children and to others.

As there is no agreement about the importance of heredity versus environment in influencing child development, a bio-psychosocial model accepts that both factors are, to an indeterminate degree, important and are transactionally involved with social conditions to shape development. Children are, therefore influenced by, as well as influencing, their families, their peers and siblings, and their communities. Modern Attachment Theory research stresses the role of siblings and grandparents (Dunn and Kendrick; Werner). Melhuish looked at the influence of day care provision. A child’s primary experiences set the tone of their relationships for life. Poor patterns of attachment, low self esteem, role-modelling and social expectations all contribute to a vulnerable child’s vulnerability, placing them at risk of significant harm or offending behaviours.

Services are often underdeveloped to meet such complex needs and the perception of such children easily moves from victim to perpetrator. Even well developed services are likely to be under resourced and unlikely to meet all these complex needs. In as far as there is a solution it is generally thought to lie in partnership and team working, although these are also contested concepts. Sheldon (1994) argues that treatment by a single professional has been demonstrated to work more effectively and that inter-professional working presents real difficulties when interventions may be based on mutely conflicting knowledge bases and research evidence. Inter-agency collaboration can also fail.

These experiences further damage emerging identity and self-worth and heighten the sense of loss, separation and abandonment. It is not surprising that in struggling to understand all this, many children blame themselves for their circumstances. What is not acceptable is that a child in this position should be stigmatised, excluded and blamed. Unfortunately it is also the case that the most damaged, vulnerable and difficult young people are also the ones most likely not to receive help and support from families and communities. Their geographical communities are likely to be the most deprived and their social cohesion is challenged by the multiple deprivations and discriminations discussed above. There is also a possibility of culture and value clash. Strongly diverse cultural groups may well bring values that are themselves at odds with the pervading social care value (e.g. the acceptance of corporal punishment among Jamaican communities). Professionals need to develop an open-minded, not knowing approach that values and respects others as equals. This is particular difficult in the face of strong value conflicts. Professionals will bring their own ethnic and cultural style to their interactions with service users. To a degree such difference may be overruled by professional training, which privileges intellectually based arguments and views, and yet the central importance of working with difference, creating dialogue, partnership and respect, calls this into question.

Although every child we meet is different, an individual with a unique history and background, in Britain, children who are Looked After by the social care system are frequently disadvantaged by a multitude of factors that each collide with and compound the disadvantages of others. One way of unravelling the complexity is to analyse these influences on three dimensions: Personal, Cultural and Structural. Government initiatives, legislation, policy and guidance have made consultation and involvement with service users key to service delivery. However, the lived experience for many service users is not one of involvement and consultation. Limited resources and difficult decisions over priorities, the residue of bad practice and poorly run Local Authority Social Services Departments that fail to meet Government quality control targets (e.g. multiple placement driven by budgetary considerations) further compound structural disadvantages. Managers of care services come face to face with inequalities, social disadvantage and social exclusion on a daily basis. Holman (1998) shows how different elements join together to heighten the impact of social disadvantage on families in Easterhouse in Glasgow. Such disadvantages may be overlaid by cultural factors. The thrust towards multi-culturalism (itself a contested concept) has not brought social equality uniformly to minority ethnic and cultural groups. New waves of immigration have further increased diversity and services struggle to answer to the diverse cultural and linguistic needs presented by such diversity. Although the dominant white culture may see minority ethnic groups as homogenous, in reality, Black Britain is culturally, ethnically and linguistically diverse. Simplistic attempts to provide culturally sensitive services can be at the best tokenistic. The structural dominance of white culture re-enforces exclusion and disadvantage. Those who are most excluded from society are those to whom services are frequently less responsive. Generations of social exclusion may further damage personal resources. Exclusion from quality education and health care provision limit an individual’s ability to advocate for themselves. Government attempts to move resource allocations away from the privileged may have done little more than divert them to the articulate. Safe and effective care for children relies on a developed understanding of these issues of child development, psychopathology and identity in a context of multiple disadvantage, social exclusion and discrimination. The understanding of these issues and measure to counter social disadvantage (anti-oppressive practices) need to be woven into planning from the provision of each child’s care.

The environment in which children growing up will influence the lessons they take from their childhoods. Whilst it undoubtedly true that the majority of children, even in the most deprived areas, are well socialized and pro-social, multiple disadvantages, deprivation, abuse and neglect are all risk factors for anti-social adjustment. Children who are neglected are not given the opportunity of pro-social role modelling or responsible parenting, victims of violence are more likely to see violence as acceptable. There may be competing needs of maintaining links and safeguarding. The communities that a child needs to develop a sense of self may also harbour those who have neglected, hurt and abused them. They may well be looked after by people who have little or no direct experience of their culture, religion and linguistic background. Managers need to flag theses issues up and think creatively about ways in which such needs can be met. Although every child we meet is different, an individual with a unique history and background, in Britain, children who are Looked After by the social care system are frequently disadvantaged by a multitude of factors that each collide with and compound the disadvantages of others. One way of unravelling the complexity is to analyse these influences on three dimensions: Personal, Cultural and Structural. Government initiatives, legislation, policy and guidance have made consultation and involvement with service users key to service delivery. However, the lived experience for many service users is not one of involvement and consultation. Limited resources and difficult decisions over priorities, the residue of bad practice and poorly run Local Authority Social Services Departments that fail to meet Government quality control targets (e.g. multiple placement driven by budgetary considerations) further compound structural disadvantages. Managers of care services come face to face with inequalities, social disadvantage and social exclusion on a daily basis. Holman (1998) shows how different elements join together to heighten the impact of social disadvantage on families in Easterhouse in Glasgow. Such disadvantages may be overlaid by cultural factors. The thrust towards multi-culturalism (itself a contested concept) has not brought social equality uniformly to minority ethnic and cultural groups. New waves of immigration have further increased diversity and services struggle to answer to the diverse cultural and linguistic needs presented by such diversity. Although the dominant white culture may see minority ethnic groups as homogenous, in reality, Black Britain is culturally, ethnically and linguistically diverse. Simplistic attempts to provide culturally sensitive services can be at the best tokenistic. The structural dominance of white culture re-enforces exclusion and disadvantage. Those who are most excluded from society are those to whom services are frequently less responsive. Generations of social exclusion may further damage personal resources. Exclusion from quality education and health care provision limit an individual’s ability to advocate for themselves. Government attempts to move resource allocations away from the privileged may have done little more than divert them to the articulate. Safe and effective care for children relies on a developed understanding of these issues of child development, psychopathology and identity in a context of multiple disadvantage, social exclusion and discrimination. The understanding of these issues and measure to counter social disadvantage (anti-oppressive practices) need to be woven into planning from the provision of each child’s care.

Thursday, 25 November 2010

Verbal communication

Human speech is a complex matter that has been subject to extensive study and debate. When considering our use of the spoken word it is helpful to take into account the wider context that affects and influences verbal communication. (There is not scope here to address language delay as part of specific psychological difficulties)

Emotional Climate
Our own emotional state influences our perceptions of what is being said to us, and can block the communitive process altogether. If we are wrapped up in our own feelings or concerns, we will not be sensitive to the needs and feelings of others. Communication can be seriously hampered by a lack of awareness to the emotional climate. We need to be responsive to the feelings of those we work with colleagues as well as young people so that the quality and effectiveness of our interactions can be maximised.

In listening to young people we must make sure we hear their voices and respond with an open mind, not one that is closed by unquestioned assumptions.

Developmental Level
We need to be attuned to the developmental level of the person or persons we with whom we are conversing. This relates to:

• Different levels of understanding between adults and children.
• Differences amongst children according to their level of maturity.
• Differences amongst those in terms of intelligence, educational attainment and life experience.

Failure to address these issues can undermine any attempts to develop rapport and make peoples’ problems worse by alienating them. Examples of how we do this are: speaking at a level above their heads (thereby undermining confidence and self-esteem) and by patronising them through speaking down to them.

There are no simple formulae to follow in judging the appropriate developmental level, so we need to become sensitive to such matters.

Language is a very powerful vehicle for reinforcing peoples’ low self-esteem. For example, use of critical and insensitive language by people in positions of power.

Vocal qualities
A considerable amount of information is conveyed not through what is said, but how we say it. The rate of speech, pitch, loudness and timbre of the persons’ voice speaks volumes. Try saying “Go Away” or “Shut Up” in as many different ways as possible and it is easy to recognise that often it is not so much what is said that matters, but how it is said.

Oppressive language
The potential to reinforce or exacerbate discrimination and oppression is often misunderstood and frequently trivialised. Language transmits the dominant ideas that perpetuate inequality and disadvantage. For example, socialising children into sexism by the transmission of sexist ideas and assumptions from one generation to the next.

One problem with developing sensitivity to the discriminatory potential of language is that this is often trivialised. Many people see it as a simple matter of identifying ‘bad words’ and trying to avoid them, without necessarily understanding why they should be avoided.

This approach is characterised by the term ‘political correctness’. This term is itself indicative of the deeper problem. The fact that ‘political correctness’ has become a term of ridicule illustrates the basic point: the power of language to reinforce existing power structures. Because the development of anti-discriminatory practice has cast a light on the oppressive potential of language and the need for linguistic sensitivity, a new term has been coined to undermine and discredit the focus on the power of language.

Why is language so important?
Many of the young people we work with have not had the opportunity to learn the elaborate language-code of relating. In childhood they have often missed the chance of learning productive language skills in day-to-day dialogues and conversations with adults. Many of the adults who have cared for these children in the important early years of development may themselves have had restricted opportunities to develop this elaborate language-code.

Most of the young people with whom we work need to learn the skills of relating to people, to conduct satisfying relationships by applying recognisable verbal and non-verbal skills. Children learn by example, we are their role models. We need to encourage and enable the young people to understand that there are other ways of relating and to recognise the power of their language. They need to know that it is not only desirable, but also possible to change the way they speak.

Finally
It has been suggested by some language experts that up to 85% of communication is non-verbal, through tone of voice and inflection, body language, etc. It is helpful to reflect on the language that we use and the way we use that language.

Saturday, 4 September 2010

Developing the children's workforce

The attachment network offers training courses that provide a psychodynamic, therapeutic approach to the residential and fostering task and equips frontline staff and their managers with the knowledge base and skills to work with vulnerable children and young people with Attachment in mind. The basis of a psychodynamic approach is that any individual’s current experience is most effectively understood with some reference to their inner world: their early childhood experiences and their mental processes. Key to this work is unpacking and developing the practice skills that workers require. Training focuses on ongoing relationships, rather than maladaptive behaviours, and considers how to create and sustain a safe place in which recovery from early childhood trauma can begin, taking account of the child’s real life experiences and their mind sets.

Providing a holist approach to the therapeutic task, courses are underpinned by a coherent theoretical position, drawing on attachment theory, humanistic psychology, social learning theory and contemporary cognitive psychology. The training takes account of current research and the extensive practice experience of the trainers. The child is seen not as an adult in waiting, but as a competent being in their own right, full of potential, and expert in their own experience, a view of childhood now adopted by social pedagogy.

We can also offer workshop days tailored to your organization’s requirements. These days are often used to supplement more formal training and help staff integrate the training fully into their practice.

Visit www.attachment-network.org and find out more

Sunday, 6 June 2010

Panic and unthinkable anxiety

Emotional and behavioural difficulties encompass a wide range of difficulties and needs and include both problems which manifest in either emotional or behavioural terms and problems which have both emotional and behavioural dimensions (Maras and Redmayne 1997). At an extreme these difficulties may be experienced as fear and rage and can manifest as violence to self, to carers, to peers, to others. This fear and rage is very like the ‘panic’ states described by Dockar-Drysdale (1990). Both states are similar to what Winnicott (1965) described as state of ‘unthinkable anxiety’. Winnicott spells out these ‘unthinkable anxieties’ or ‘primitive agonies’ as:
• Feelings of going to pieces
• Falling forever
• Having no relation to the body
• Having no orientation
• Complete isolation because of there being no means of communication
(collated in Davis and Wallbridge 1981)

It appears that these young people lack the internal image of arms that can safely hold, of a mind and face that responds to pain and joy – of a mother that can soothe terrors, of a father that can keep monsters at bay. (Woodhead 2001).

Many of the young people with whom we will work are in the care of local authorities and one of the defining characteristics is a seeming inability to tolerate the experience of being cared for in families in the community. Professionals have frequently defined their needs in terms of conditions such as autism, aspergers syndrome, attention deficit, dyslexia, depression, conduct disorder and attachment disorder. They may be regarded by adults as manipulative, attention seeking, irritating, untrustworthy, selfish, difficult and frustrating to manage.

The child’s primary care-giver and the relationships closest to him will have created the images built up. However the inner world soon builds and extends to siblings, friends, teachers and others. A complicated network of personal images of the self and others emerges. For children who experience serious disruption and distortion, it becomes difficult to create such images and sustain a ‘sense of me’ (Ward1998). For children who experience abuse, sexual, physical or emotional, the whole picture becomes distorted and painful (Ward. 1998).

For young people in the care system this can be extremely painful as they also have to bear the feelings of loss. We all experience loss in our lives and many children will suffer the loss of someone close to them, for example a grandparent. We learn to cope with losses such as this, with appropriate support, as part of our development. However many children in the care system will not only have the loss and separation from their families but also loss of foster families, as the breakdown of foster placements is an all too familiar event. I have worked with young people who have had as many as seventy different foster placements. How can these young people gather together experiences into any meaningful or positive whole? They don’t, they become numb to any further attachment, to protect themselves from further pain.

Unintegrated young people will not have experienced a meaningful attachment, for them loss will more likely to be experienced as instinctual painful feelings which they most likely will not be able to acknowledge or express in any way, they do not know how to grieve, they are more likely to experience rage and envy. These feelings of rage and envy will often be ‘acted out’ when triggered by something else disconnected from the original feelings. This ‘acting out’ behaviour happens because the child has no other way of communicating. Dockar-Drysdale (1990) states that all ‘acting out’ is a breakdown in communication and it is the responsibility of the worker to keep in communication with the child. She discusses the importance of being careful to respond when the child reaches out to us. This is what Winnicott described as the most important thing in the child’s early emotional development, the sensitive response of the primary care giver, to the child’s needs.

If we are going to be able to help these children we need to be clear about the task. Understanding a child’s early primary care experience helps us think about their present needs. Learning to deduce the emotional content of the child’s early experiences provides an understanding of each child. We need to help the children come to know, that their needs will be met within a consistent containing predictable and loving way. This is essential in the therapeutic task.

Holding and containment provide a safe world with boundaries, within which relationships with others can be negotiated. Children who have not experienced sufficient holding and containment demonstrate this with chaotic and disruptive behaviour. A major part of the task is then to provide a safe world where they can develop a secure base on which to grow.

The holding environment and therapeutic childcare
Winnicott (1965) used the term ‘ holding environment’ to refer to the totality of the parents’ provision of physical and metaphorical holding of its emotional well-being. This metaphor has been extended to incorporate the total treatment environment in which care and treatment is provided for in a range of residential settings including children’s units.

The holding environment will consist of a number of key elements:
• Provision of appropriate boundaries on behaviour and expression of emotions, strong feelings can be expressed but do not get ‘out of hand’.
• Providing an element of ‘giving’ and tolerance in relationships, so that people will feel genuinely cared for and where appropriate, looked after; the ‘giving’ in the relationship may also include some degree of interpretation or at least ‘reaching out’ in communication.
• Appropriate containment of anxiety (see Bion 1962) for example the adult can take the anxiety on for the child, conveying to the child that the problem will be managed by the adult and child together until they are able to manage it alone.
• Working towards maximum clarity in communication. Misunderstandings need to be resolved. People under stress may interpret things in a distorted way. People feeling ‘unheld’ may feel undervalued or persecuted. (Ward, A.1998 and 2003).
• We must also take into account the provision of appropriate ‘holding’ for the staff team who are engaged in the ‘holding process’. The quality of the ‘holding environment’ of staff is the determinant of the quality of the holding environment for the children. This is created by the organisation and the process of management. (Miller 1993).
• The ‘culture’ in which thinking is embedded. How physical and structural holding mechanisms are understood and founded on staff thinking together (Ward, A. 2003).
• The children need to feel they are being held in mind. Care and thinking needs to be underpinned by what Winnicott calls ‘primary maternal preoccupation’ (Winnicott 1958). That is in order to develop mentally one must not be forgotten.(Ward, A. 2003).

Managing violence in children and young people
Winnicott argued that unintegrated children cannot contain violent feelings. We need to help them to communicate, by listening and responding appropriately. The therapeutic task at this stage is to hold onto the child, survive the attacks and manage the behaviour, until they can begin to control themselves.

In a lecture on deprivation and delinquency and work in substitute caring, Winnicott (1970) shortly before his death said, ‘it may be a kind of loving but often it has to look like a kind of hating, and the key word is not treatment or cure but rather it’s survival. If you survive then the child has a chance to grow and become something like the person he or she would have been if the untoward environmental breakdown had not brought disaster. Children who have experienced trauma and environmental breakdown need adults who can allow them to process their rage and who can survive their angry attacks.

All children and young people who enter substitute care require the most sensitive understanding of their difficulties experienced in their development. Bettelheim (1950) in his book “Love is Not Enough” stated that love alone would not effect change in working with disturbed children and young people. If they have the opportunity to change they have to be able to express and work with their destructive, hateful feelings and they have much to feel enraged about. The roots of their disturbance, and the intensity of their pain and the powerful effects it has on others needs to be understood and survived by their substitute carers. For their pain to be relieved and their development to be freed, they need an approach which is sensitive to their inner world.

Assessment of integrated/non-integrated child
The un-integrated child shows both panic and disruption
Panic, often described as a temper tantrum, is the hallmark of un-integration. It represents traumatic, unthinkable experience at an early age. It produces claustrophobia, agoraphobia, states of disorientation, and a total loss of identity. The victim may become immobilized in a state beyond terror, but is more likely to hit out, scream, destroy things and attack other people.
Disruption, often described as anti-social behaviour, is easily recognized. The child comes into contact with other, functioning children and immediately, compulsively breaks into the group and breaks up their activity (work or play). Un-integrated children break down into violence at times of total disintegration. They cannot contain violent feelings. It is only possible to accept responsibility with a functioning ego. This is not present in these children, and therefore, the staff have to supply the functioning ego themselves, and hold both the child and the violence together.

Obsessive Compulsive Disorder (OCD)

OCD is a neuropsychiatric illness:
* Neuro: originates in the brain
* Psychiatric: affects thoughts, feelings and behaviours

It is predominantly biological. Obsessions sometimes develop after a major stressful experience, but that does not mean the obsession is caused by the experience, or is a natural reaction to it. Mostly, OCD starts insidiously, without rhyme or reason.

Although it is not caused by stress in the environment, it can be triggered or made worse by environmental factors, and stress makes OCD more difficult to resist.

Typically, people with OCD have insight (at least some of the time) into how irrational their thinking is. They may be secretive and shameful about their obsessive thoughts, and may conceal the condition for years. “OCD tricks you into thinking what it wants you to do makes sense, but nothing about OCD is real”. Intrusive thoughts bring feelings of shame and guilt, “Just because OCD makes you feel bad, that doesn’t mean you are bad”.
People with OCD frequently also suffer from depression.

Definition: OCD
* Obsessions and/or compulsions that are time consuming, distressing and/or interfere with normal routines, relationships and daily functioning

Obsessions
* Persistent impulses, ideas images, or thoughts that intrude into a person’s thinking and cause excessive worry and anxiety

Compulsions
* Mental states or repetitive behaviours performed in response to obsessions to relieve or prevent worry and anxiety
* Often have the intent to magically prevent some dreaded event

OCD is not the person, it is an illness; a misfiring of the system that in other people turns off our alarm system once a worrying thought has registered and been assessed. A feedback loop is established and the person feels the only escape from the worry is to perform magic rituals.

What OCD is saying to the child may not be obvious, but obsessions are so intrusive that they interfere with many parts of life. Sometimes it is possible to know the trigger for an OCD attack, but not always. Knowing the trigger can help us be more empathetic, but changing the behaviour that keeps OCD going is the key to stopping the sequence of events that is OCD. Performing the compulsions feeds the OCD, which demands more and more from the child. Left untreated, obsessions expand, morph and multiply.

Basic types
* Checkers
* Washers/cleaners
* Pure Obsessionals
* Hoarders
* People with scrupulosity (religious, moral, ethical)


Working with OCD
Gradually learning to resist the same compulsions reduces the obsessive thoughts. By taking control of how they respond to OCD, the young person can change the brain so that OCD brain responses are replaced by normal ones.

Important conversation: taking risks
“If I don’t do my rituals, what will I do to feel safe?”
By taking a chance and dealing with discomfort by not doing rituals, you open up other ways of handling discomfort.

“If I confront my fear of germs, how can I guarantee that the catastrophe I fear will not happen?” You cannot guarantee a life free of risk, pain loss, etc. The problem is your brain has made the mistaken connection between your compulsions and feelings of comfort and safety. Exposure-Response Prevention (ERP) can help break the stranglehold they have on your life.

NICE guideline for treating OCD
The main treatments for children and young people:
* Talking to someone and getting help with anxious feeling from thoughts or actions
* Mild symptoms - given a self-help book to help thoughts and actions. Healthcare professional should help to follow some of the exercises in the book. Family or carers may be given information about OCD and the treatments
* If the exercises do not help, or person does not want to try them, they should be offered a Cognitive Behavioural therapy including exposure and response prevention (CBT with ERP)
* Family or carers should be involved in the treatment
* Offered the choice treatment alone, or with a group
* For more severe symptoms CBT with ERP should be offered.

Medication
* Medication can help children and young people with OCD but they should be offered therapy before medication
* Medication offered also dependent on age. It is less likely to be offered to very young children
* Usually person should be having CBT withy ERP while taking medicine
* SSRIs (antidepressants) often work best for people with OCD
* Only offered medicines being seen by a child and adolescent psychiatrist

Evidence from research
There is a growing body of research that indicates that CBT with ERP is an effective treatment for pediatric OCD. A meta-analysis of research by Barnet et al (2008) found that remission rates varied between 40% and 85% for exposure based CBT. O’Kearney (2007) compared the research on expose based CBT interventions with medication only and with no treatment and found a 37% improvement in remission rates in the treatment groups. There was no significant difference between CBT and medication. CBT combined with medication offered potential for best health outcomes.

Cognitive Behavioural Therapy with Exposure and Response
Prevention (CBT with ERP)
CBT is a psychological treatment based on the idea that the way we feel is affected by our thoughts (or ‘cognitions’) and beliefs, and by how we behave. For example, a negative thought can lead to negative behaviour, which can affect feelings. CBT helps people to reassess the meaning of their thoughts and actions.

ERP consists of two parts: exposure to feared situations, thoughts or images, and response prevention, the voluntary blocking of compulsive behaviors. ERP requires the supervised or self-controlled blocking of compulsive rituals. This needs willingness to tolerate high levels of discomfort and it involves purposefully allowing anxiety to be present

Exposure relies on two related learning processes: habituation and extinction. It an be thought of as a behavioural experiment, a way of the individual gathering evidence from their own experience that the way hey currently understand the world is distorted.

Habituation harnesses the nervous system’s natural tendency to numb out to repeated and prolong contact with a stimulus. Extinction uses the way behaviour is governed by its consequences. Because the ritual brings relief from the anxiety that accompanies the obsession, the obsession is reinforced. When the ritual response is prevented, it no longer reinforces the obsession.

Exposure can be in therapy, but can also be in vivo, the prolonged, face-to-face confrontation in real-life with anxiety provoking situations, objects, thoughts or images.Once the response is blocked, the brain has the opportunity to provide the natural habituation to the fear-provoking situation, and more realistic and adaptive interpretations can replace the fearful ones. For response prevention to be effective it is necessary to eliminate, block or contain all the behaviours that neutralize or lessen the feelings of anxiety and discomfort brought on by the obsessions, and purposefully allowing the anxiety to be present.

Obsessive thoughts without obvious compulsions can still be treated with CBT with ERP. However the ERP will focus on mental rituals and any methods used to deal with obsessive thoughts.

Cognitive therapy for OCD
Most psychological treatment for OCD consists of CBT with ERP, but if someone does not feel comfortable starting ERP they may be offered cognitive therapy that has been adapted for people with OCD. Cognitive therapy can help people change their beliefs about things they may find distressing, but it does not usually involve being ‘exposed’ to what makes them frightened or anxious as in ERP.

CBT involves actively challenging and confronting the distorted thinking and beliefs that drive and maintain the obsessions and compulsions. Table 1 lists the key cognitive errors of people with OCD.


Cognitive error
Example
Black-and-White or All-or Nothing Thinking
If I’m not completely safe, then I’m in overwhelming danger
Magical Thinking
If I think bad thoughts, bad things will happen
Over-estimating Risk
If I take eve a slight risk, I will come to great harm
Perfectionism
I’ve got to do everything perfectly
Hyper-morality
I’ll be punished for every mistake
Over-responsibility for Others
I must always guard against making mistakes that even remotely harm an innocent person
Over-importance of Thought
If I think about a terrible event occurring, it is much more likely to happen
Exclusivity Error
Bad things are much more likely to happen to me than to other people
Martyr Complex
Suffering and sacrificing my life by doing endless rituals is a small price to pay to protect those I love. Since no harm has come to them, I must be doing something right
“What If” Thinking
In the future, what if I get it wrong
Intolerance of uncertainty
I can’t relax until I am 100% certain of everything, and know everything will be OK

Other than the treatments described above, there is no evidence that other psychological treatments or therapies can help improve OCD.
These include psychoanalysis, transactional analysis, and hypnosis.

CBT is a time limited intervention. Typically, a client may see the therapist for anything from six weeks to three months. It is also very hard work. It is a challenging approach, and may involve homework, for example keeping a journal. More recently, CBT has begun to emphasise the therapeutic alliance more, acknowledging that therapy proceeds within a relationship, and therefore, in common with other psychotherapies, in order for CBT to be effective, the client must feel able to invest in the therapist. It is not enough to be referred and just turn up.

Supporting recovery
* Realize that a person with OCD cannot control the powerful urges they experience. A chemical imbalance is ruling their thoughts and behaviours
* Never force or impose treatment or help
* Do not criticise or scold if they cannot meet expectations
* Encourage, guide, monitor, help and support
* Do not judge the person with OCD by their progress
* Expect relapses
* Reward progress with praise
* Expect the symptoms to make no sense
* Do not expect the symptoms to have symbolic meaning; they are just OCD

Warning: “enabling” OCD
It is important to avoid enabling the OCD by colluding with the rituals by offering reassurance, and by accommodating the OCD.

Assessment
A thorough assessment of OCD obsessions and compulsions is the first step to breaking free. This is usually conducted through as self-report questionnaire that identifies an individual’s obsessions and compulsions and assigns a past and present disruption score to each.

It can be overwhelming to think of making improvements to each symptom at once, but the road to recovery is taken one step at a time, singling out one or two symptoms that are casing the most disruption to everyday life.

The Residential Task (Part 1)

Although developmental difficulties can be recovered from in nurturing social relationships, children with attachment difficulties display a range of problematic behaviours. Some of these behaviours are the child’s still immature attempts to have their primary needs met, some are learnt in a history of broken, breaking and disrupted relationships: the child’s internal disturbances act out in the world, which finds them disturbing and disturbed, and so frequently responding to them from bewilderment or anger, and sometimes fear or hostility; responses that confirm the child self-other belief that they are worthless and unwanted and others are rejecting and hostile. However, attachment behaviour are an intrinsic aspect of human nature, and the expression of attachment behaviours later in life is neither regrettable nor regressive, as it is often labelled, but is a result of the individual attempting to find a secure base with an available attachment figure.

The developmental niche
The environment in which a child grows up greatly influences their development. There are many influences in this environment, but in their early years their caregivers’ beliefs, values and ways of caring are the most significant. As the child develops and explores, peer relationships become increasingly influential. They are also influenced by teachers, relatives’, and activities in the community and greater society. These influences can be thought of providing a developmental niche that is different for each child. However, development is not a one-way process; when exploring their world the child is both influenced by it and an influence upon it.

A child thrives the developmental niche is a good fit to the needs of the child, but if there is a poor fit between the child’s needs and their developmental niche, it is stressful for all concerned, the child is like “a square peg” forced into “a round hole”. The child will develop behaviours that provide ways of coping with these pressures, behaviours which may further d=reduce the goodness of fit. In extreme cases a child’s healthy development can be significantly impaired.


Attachment
Attachment is a relationship played out across time and contexts with a particular partner. Attachment resolves two competing drives: to explore and to be safe. These drives are reconciled by through the proximity, the sensitive responsiveness and the availability of the attachment figure. When this is “good enough”, a secure relationship develops, in which both child and attachment figure find satisfaction. A primary caregiver who is predictable and sensitively responsive engenders in the child feeling of trust and security. The relationship becomes as secure base for exploration and a safe haven at times of danger, and so most infants learn to deal with stressful circumstances and negative emotions in an organized manner. However, when caregiving is not “good enough”, the child can become anxious that their need for comfort and safety will not be met. Although the child may feel insecure, they are still able to organize their thinking and feeling about the attachment figure in a manner in which these unmet needs are partially resolved.

Disorganized attachment
However, a primary caregiver who is frightening and unpredictable leaves the child with an unsolvable dilemma: “do I approach or do I avoid (for comfort and safety)”. Traumatized by severe neglect and/or abuse, such a child is left with fear without a solution; they are unable to organize their internal world in a way that can be relied upon to have attachment needs met.

By age six, these children are beginning to organize their behaviour in ways that controls this approach-avoidance dilemma. Whilst they remain unable to form an organized mental representation of the attachment figure, they may acquire a brittle layer of coping skills. In order to control the fear that is intertwined with the attachment figure the child may create a kind of role-reversal, beginning to control and dominate the attachment figure through controlling and punitive behaviours. Punitive-controlling behaviours seek to keep the attachment figure from occupying the role of the carer, as it is too frightening to let the helpless/hostile carer be in control. The child begins to be hostile, aggressive and directive towards the attachment figure. Interactions are intended to humiliate them into submission, or aggressively control the attachment figure. The child takes responsibility for their own care and protection and never seeks adult advice, guidance or protection. They generalize these controlling behaviours onto other adults.

Whilst some children are unable to develop even these brittle coping skills and remain disorganized and unresolved, others become controlling overbright-caregiving, taking on the role of parenting and controlling their parents. Overbright-caregiving behaviours develop when the attachment figure’s needs, vulnerabilities and dependencies take precedence over the child’s. The child is frightened by the adult’s helplessness and cannot find an attachment strategy to increase security. As a way of attempting to engage the attachment figure, the child begins to act like a parent towards the adult, who responds by emphasising their own dependence on the child’s precocious qualities. The child directs the parent’s interaction in a helpful, positive manner, and is excessively cheery, polite and helpful. They are orientated to protect the parent. The child’s needs are suppressed and remain beneath the child’s petrified surface, erupting as rage or panic when the child is under pressure.


Faced with these attempts at control, parents can feel hostile and helpless, overwhelmed and that their very integrity is threatened. Under such threat, caregivers need to defend themselves, and caught in the child’s hostility, can feel either that the child is impossible or that they are not up to the job of caring for them.

Mentalizing
Two systems in the human brain that seem to be closely linked are the attachment system and the area of the brain that allows us to think about other people’s mental states. The ability to carry out this process, called mentalizing, is reduced when the attachment system is activated by a threat. In evolutionary terms this makes sense. Under threat, to think about your own danger and signal for safety through proximity kept early humans alive. If the mental state of eh other was thought about, that may seem more important than the threat. Child with highly anxious attachments are frequently hyper-vigilant, and hyper-aroused; states that are accompanied by reduced capacity to consider the mental states of others.

Recovery
Although often overlooked, a powerful intervention to promote recovery is organized at the level of the caregiving system. This can be thought of as operating at two levels: the psycho-social environment and individual parenting style.

The psycho-social environment needs to sooth arousal and support and enable exploration. This requires consistency and predictability, but also requires that over restriction is guarded against: the planned environment promotes safety and exploration. Caregivers can manage the child’s arousal level by adjusting the elements of structure and challenge, as if pulling levers in response to the child’s needs.


Parenting style is a product of beliefs and values interacting with experience. Some of our core beliefs and assumptions may be hidden from our immediate gaze. Although therapeutic work has a mystique around it, we should not underestimate the work done by carers who have intimate knowledge of the child. They may be the child’s most valuable resource.
Therapeutic parenting supports therapy, but also attempts to diminish intensity of the memories, emotions, bodily sensations, thoughts by allowing the child to revise memories of past trauma in a safe environment. Progress is likely to be slow, the child can remain stuck in their familiar ways and it takes time to learn to trust being dependent yet safe. But, recovery happens in relationships with others who are attentive and sensitive to the child’s performance, and provide helpful and encouraging response to difficulties and success.

Therapeutic parenting requires adults who are appropriately mindful of their own needs, and are able to set and maintain boundaries. The child’s recovery requires that they can set and high expectations for now and future development, and that these expectations are accompanied by good explanation of expectations, boundaries, actions and choices. These two elements of therapeutic parenting are bound together by authentic, unconditional warmth. The child can explore the world around, and return knowing that they will be welcomed, physically and emotionally nourished, comforted and reassured.

Supporting and enabling
Therapeutic work requires explicit expectations and clear explanations (against a backdrop of authentic warmth). The consequences of actions need to be well understood and made explicit, and individuals nhttp://www.blogger.com/pages.g?blogID=1824609228345427485eed to be (or become) responsible for their own actions. Left to their own devices, the child may not be able to make progress, so it is our task to make explicit how we will support and enable progress. The child’s primitive coping places us under a huge pressure that we will at times inevitably be defended against, either rejecting the child for their behaviour or feeling overwhelmed by their pain.

Supporting caregivers
Caregivers carry the burden of the emotional labour of the work, and to promote recovery they too need supporting and enabling. Support needs to be matched to their needs. The bleak terror of the child’s inner world can leave us uncertain and defended. Like the recovering child, the caregiver needs to know there is nothing so terrible it cannot be talked about.